Bucket List - Long Island
WEEKEND · EVENTS · THINGS TO DO · EAT & DRINK · TOWNS · SEARCH
Long Island / Eat & Drink / Claws Seafood Market
RESTAURANT · WEST SAYVILLE
Claws Seafood Market
A frequent winner of the lobster roll debate.

Good to know
Where 20 Main Street, West Sayville, West Sayville
An unpretentious New England-style market and clam shack that keeps winning the best-on-the-island debate.
Hours and prices change. Check with the business before you go.
Magical Deserts
Morocco
Misty Mountains
Scotland
Exotic Urbanism
Brazil
FEATURED IN
Lobster Rolls on Long Island
Bucket List LI
The best things to do, eat and explore across Nassau and Suffolk.
This weekend · Events · Things to do · Eat & drink · Fall · With kids · Nassau · Suffolk · Towns
About · Contact · Advertise · List your event · Search
© 2026 Bucket List LI. All rights reserved.